Who Rose, Who Fell, and Who Got Robbed
The leaderboard has officially been updated.
And yes — before you ask — I am aware this will cause discourse.
Some men rose.
Others fell.
Some were emotionally removed from their positions against my will.
To see the original rankings, you can find their positions immortalized here: The very first book boyfriend leaderboard
✨ If you’re new here: this leaderboard ranks fantasy romance men based on actual dateability — not just vibes.
Think loyalty, emotional intelligence, and “would I recommend him to a friend” energy.
Let’s begin.
🏆 The New Top Five Book Boyfriends
- Fanfiction Draco Malfoy
- Aaron Warner
- King Raphael
- King Cyrus
- Prince Ezryn
To see the full list of book boyfriends topping the chart, visit the leaderboard here
🌒 New Honorable Mentions
- Kaan Vaegor
- Captain Nolan Astor (Hook)
- Rorrik
- Death
Still elite. Still dangerous. Just not top ten material… for now.
⬆️ Who Rose
These are the men who proved themselves.
Not by hype. Not by nostalgia.
But by showing up and refusing to be ignored.
Aaron Warner
Warner didn’t just stay relevant — he evolved.
Older. Sharper. More self-aware.
The kind of man who refuses to remain stagnant while the story around him deepens.
He grows with the narrative, and honestly? That’s rare.
So yes — he rises.
📖 Read his story: Shatter Me by Tahereh Mafi
Fanfiction Draco Malfoy
This feels unfair. Because it is.
Draco is not one man — he’s an entire ecosystem.
He can be:
- dark and unhinged in an AU
- powerful and controlled as an auror
- soft and broken in redemption arcs
- devastatingly devoted in ways canon never fully allowed
He adapts. Shifts. He becomes whatever version of him the story demands.
And that flexibility?
That’s exactly why he sits at the top.
📖 Read his stories: The Best Dramione Fanfiction of 2026
⬇️ Who Fell
Some men didn’t lose value.
They just got outpaced.
Rhysand
You may be wondering how this happened.
So am I.
Once untouchable. Now sitting… not in the top 5.
Still powerful. Still iconic.
But the competition has evolved, and so have I.
He’ll likely fight his way back up when more of his story unfolds — but for now, he takes a step back.
📖 Read his story: A Court of Thorns and Roses by Sarah J. Maas
Prince Caspian
Complicated case.
Ezryn exists. And Ezryn is connected to Caspian’s mate.
So yes — technically this is a situation that embraces “why choose.”
But this is a ranking, not a group project.
Between Cas and Ezryn?
Ezryn won.
No further questions.
📖 Read his story: Bonded by Thorns by Elizabeth Helen
Blake
Blake didn’t fall.
He was pushed.
Ezryn entered the chat and simply… changed the hierarchy.
Some men can’t survive that kind of arrival.
📖 Read his story: The Wolf King by Lauren Palphreyman
🆕 Who Got Robbed (But Stayed Standing)
These men didn’t make the top ten — but they weren’t dismissed.
They were nearly there.
- Kaan — too good to remove entirely. So he lives on in honorable mentions.
- Captain Nolan Astor (Hook) — dangerously compelling, but missing one key data point: spice-level certainty.
- Rorrik — still lethal, still loyal, still underestimated.
- Death — morally questionable, emotionally effective.
They’re not gone.
They are simply waiting for the next shift in power.
💔 Who Disappeared (No Longer in Rotation)
This part hurts.
Not because they’re bad.
But because space is limited, and standards are not.
- Samkiel from Gods and Monsters series by Amber V. Nicole
- Luka from The Legacy series by Melissa K. Roehrich
- Patrick from The Artisan Trilogy by Stacey McEwan
They didn’t fail.
They were simply outmatched.
And in this system?
That’s enough.
💭 Final Thoughts
This leaderboard is not static.
It evolves with every new book, every new obsession, every new fictional man who thinks he can do better.
Some men will rise again.
While others will fall further.
And some will reclaim their throne.
Me?
I’ll be over here updating rankings like it’s a full-time emotional job.
👉 View the current Book Boyfriend Leaderboard here
Proceed accordingly. 😌📚🔥
Make it Your Own
Want to create your own book boyfriend leaderboard? I’ve got you.
Leave a Reply